Friday, November 16, 2007

A theory of everything triples traffic

A. Garrett Lisi doesn't know why bosons can't be added with fermions and why spinors can't be added with scalars and vectors, among many other things. But he has made it. ;-)

The term "a theory of everything" in the title together with a bunch of unusually stupid journalists is enough to do so.

A female surfer was picked instead of AGL to enforce affirmative action.

The Telegraph, The Ottawa Citizen, and other outlets have made this crackpot so famous that even humble blogs such as this one have seen their traffic triple yesterday as a consequence. On Thursday, TRF had over 9,000 unique visitors and on Friday over 14,000 unique visitors. Everyone is thrilled with the "E8 theory of everything". Well, people are rather excitable. ;-)

Good for them. Bad for the wisdom of the society.


  1. You should probably blame reddit. I didn't read a theory of everything, but have subscribed here, so yippee for you!

  2. This is called the Slashdot effect and has nothing to do with quantum physics.

  3. Both of you are partly correct ;-) and others would be, too. The traffic goes from direct Google searches for Garrett Lisi, his paper's title, from Digg, Reddit, Slashdot discussion, Not Even Woit, Wikipedia, and many other blogs, discussion forums, and sources.

  4. Dear Lubos,

    I would imagine that Lisi is working on specific predictions of as-yet-undiscovered particles, as we write these words. Lisi has already stated that these predictions will be either proven right or else his theory will fail spectacularly. To me, this sounds a lot more like science than string theory, which makes a lot of noise and occupies much valuable mindspace, yet offers few (if any) testable predictions.

    Will you apologise to Lisi for the unscientific insults you have levelled upon him, if next year the LHC validates the particle predictions he is about to make?

  5. Dear George, Lisi doesn't have any predictions for the LHC, so whether I answer Yes or No to your question is absolutely inconsequential. I can answer Yes to make you happier. Best, Lubos

  6. We thought you might be interested --

    Inquiring into the Origin of Matter and Life
    January-March 2008
    Bhaktivedanata Institute's latest quarterly newsletter
    is now available online.
    You can download the January-March 2008 issue from:

    ____________ _________ _________ ____________ _________ _________ __

    What's it about?
    Modern science has generally been directed toward investigating
    the material world, excluding consideration of the conscious
    scientist who is essential to the whole process, since, of
    course, the very existence of the scientific endeavor itself
    depends upon consciousness. Complete scientific knowledge must
    consequently include both objective science and subjective

    In addition to other programs, Bhaktivedanta Institute's Science
    and Scientist Newsletter is humbly offered to inspire scientists
    and scholars to contribute their sincere efforts toward
    developing this grand synthesis. The result will be valuable not
    only for helping to better understand the "hard" problems of
    science such as the nature and origin of life and the cosmos, the
    mind-brain connection, artificial intelligence, etc. But the
    pressing problems of ethics in science, world peace, and
    interfaith dialog will also benefit from a more inclusive
    scientific worldview.

    In our modern era science and religion are the predominating
    influences determining the fate of mankind. Promoting and
    developing a culture of harmony between such diverse fields has
    the potential to expand our conception of reality and advance
    human knowledge in the new millennium, in which it is said the
    study of life will be pre-eminent. Let us welcome the dawn of
    that new epoch with great hope and determined endeavor.
    ____________ _________ _________ ____________ _________ _________ __

    Newsletter Homepage:

    Newsletter Subscription:

    Please send comments/questions to: